Deliberating over legislative ends An inventory of goal-(de)legitimizing argument schemes
Artículo
![Thumbnail](/themes/Mirage2/images/cubierta.jpg)
Open/ Download
Access note
Acceso a solo metadatos
Publication date
2020Metadata
Show full item record
Cómo citar
Ihnen Jory, Constanza
Cómo citar
Deliberating over legislative ends An inventory of goal-(de)legitimizing argument schemes
Author
Abstract
This paper outlines a non-exhaustive inventory of presumptive argument schemes that can be used by legislators to rationally argue for and against the legitimacy of legislative ends. The inventory has both a descriptive and normative dimension. The inventory is descriptive because it is partly based on the empirical observation of arguments actually used by legislators in a sample of lawmaking debates. However, the inventory is also normative because - as I shall argue in this paper - the schemes identified in the sample are presumptive arguments schemes. They are therefore schemes with a claim to rationality, provided that certain conditions are met. The schemes included in the inventory are: the scheme of instrumental argumentation, the scheme from unintended consequences, the scheme from values, the schemes from model and antimodel, and the schemes from social demand.
Patrocinador
CONICYT FONDECYT/INICIACION 2016
11160149
Indexation
Artículo de publicación SCOPUS
Quote Item
Journal of Argumentation in Context Volumen: 9 Número: 3 Páginas: 399-427 Dec 2020
Collections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Pichihueche Mellado, Roberto (Universidad de Chile, 2012)The present study is intended to research into intermediate TEFL students’ development of their ability to use some of the basic argumentative writing resources that they are expected to develop as part of their academic ...
-
Pichihueche Mellado, Roberto (Universidad de Chile, 2012)En un amplio contexto de investigación, el presente estudio abarca los dominios de, por un lado, el análisis interdisciplinario del discurso y, por otro lado, el de la lingüística aplicada. El estudio estaba destinado a ...
-
Pommier, AO (Sociedad Medica de Santiago, 2020)